Our Menu

Crafted with Passion

From classic favorites to signature creations, every pizza is made from scratch with the finest ingredients.

Hand-Tossed Pizzas

Our signature thin crust, hand-stretched and baked to golden perfection. Each pie is a masterpiece of flavor.

Classic Margherita — San Marzano tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, basil
Pepperoni Supreme — Double pepperoni, house sauce, mozzarella
Veggie Delight — Bell peppers, mushrooms, olives, onions, tomatoes
Meat Lovers — Pepperoni, sausage, ham, bacon, ground beef
Karlys Special — Our signature creation with premium toppings

Specialty Items

Beyond pizza — our specialty dishes are crafted to satisfy every craving.

Garlic Knots — Butter-garlic brushed, served with marinara dip
Cheese Ravioli — Stuffed pasta in rich tomato sauce
Chicken Parmesan — Breaded chicken, marinara, melted cheese
Caesar Salad — Crisp romaine, parmesan, house croutons
Italian Sub — Layered meats, cheeses, veggies on hoagie

Drinks & Desserts

Complete your meal with our refreshing beverages and sweet treats.

Soft Drinks — Coca-Cola, Sprite, Ginger Ale, and more
Bottled Water — Still and sparkling
Tiramisu — Classic Italian coffee-flavored dessert
Cannoli — Crisp shells filled with sweet ricotta
Biscotti — Italian almond cookies, perfect with coffee

Ready to Order?

Call us or stop by — we're ready to serve you.

(732) 382-3325

Chef preparing fresh pizza in the kitchen

Our Story

A Tradition of Excellence

For over 15 years, Karlys Pizza has been a cornerstone of the Colonia community. What started as a small family dream has grown into a beloved local institution where every guest feels like family.

Our commitment is simple: use the freshest ingredients, prepare everything from scratch, and serve every pizza with the care and attention it deserves. That's why neighbors keep coming back, generation after generation.

Since 2009

Serving Colonia with pride

100%

Fresh, quality ingredients

Find Us

Visit Karlys

We're located in the heart of Colonia, ready to welcome you with warm hospitality and delicious food.

Our Location

498 Inman Ave
Colonia, NJ 07067

Call Us

(732) 382-3325

For orders and inquiries

Hours of Operation

Monday – Thursday 11:00 AM – 10:00 PM

Friday – Saturday 11:00 AM – 11:00 PM

Sunday 12:00 PM – 9:00 PM

Taste the Difference

Experience the flavors that have made Karlys Pizza a Colonia favorite for over a decade. Every bite is made with love.

Call (732) 382-3325 Get Directions

Every Slice Tells a Story